Can't put Roethlisburger on that list. He just hasn't played long enough. And though he has made some amazingly accurate passes in big situations, he doesn't do it consistantly enough. Time will tell. This moment he's not in the top 50. Just too young.
Basically, if Ben quit now, he would probably not make the HOF. So I can't put him on the list.
But it's just my list. And I love me some me.