on your profile it says you're in Alpine, NJ. I live in Bergen County also and I can tell you that the difference between Newark and Alpine is night and day (to say the least).
sorry to hear about your wheels. I'll bet my next pay check that the security guards are probably in with the retards that stole your rims.
take it from me, you'll never see those wheels again, even if you search the local body shops. Newark is a war zone, I'm a NJ State Trooper and I work in Newark.
my best advice to you is MOVE OUT OF NEWARK ASAP.