PLEASE NEED HONEST OPINION CAMARO VS MUSTANG

[08-G35s/6MT]

Originally Posted by 8cd03gro

1. Devryn17 - camaro
2. mikeSS - camaro
3. sixty4 - corvettes
4. BigDan - gt500 (the lone mustang)
5. PM Designs - camaro and trucks
6. brandotron - camaro
7. Dr.Pat - mercedes
8. newagemuscle - camaro
9. BATMANs - GTO and NSX
10. Sarah - camaro
11. Cristoff - camaro
12. a_Username - camaro
13. NBC/CGM - camaro

1/13. I MIGHT give you 12 or 11 for not including yourself and the OP. Still nowhere near 20% and only one mustang owner. Hardly the overwhelming amount of mustang owners in the thread like you were suggesting.

Maybe you should take your own advice

I am the ulterior(Non-Camaro/Horse owner) variable of this equilibrium. I say buy the horse and then let it free again...

-Or revert back to my previous post and have a car that goes on and never stops. :emoticon7:

[25thanniversary]

I would choose a camaro over a mustang anytime only mustang i would take is the super snake gt500. the looks are way better on the camaro than the mustang the rear on the mustang is ugly. i do respect them for the performance they have but being a previous mustang owner i just had to many problems with ford. and i don't see my self going back there again. yea the mustang has performance but what car has been selling the most every month the camaro. just drive both cars and choose the right car for you and enjoy them. both cars are great as long as it's american muscle.

[08-G35s/6MT]

Mustang=Camry, in terms of how common they are.

[caper]

another point...a buddy just got a pretty much loaded GT for 9k less OTD than my 2ss RS....9K!!!! thats a big difference! and i got a pretty decent deal on my car!

[newmoon]

Go stand behind a stock Mustang GT and look really hard at the backend of the car, think about paying for that back end. Then go buy the SS, LOL. No all kidding aside the GT is a nice car, possibly a tad quicker than a SS (stick vs stick, manual vs manual) the GT might handle a bit better as well. IMO I like the looks of the SS more, I prefer the interior of the SS. I was a Ford guy and really wanted to like/love the 5.0 but just couldn't. I'm hoping that in 2013-2014 Ford brings back the SVT Cobra with a new body style.

[JerseyMonte]

Originally Posted by sixty4

Thinking about pulling the trigger. My problem is a friend owns a 2ss and says its kind of boring? I drove it not all that bad. Says the performance is just not there? If he had to do it again said he would go with a Mustang.
So my problem is a Camaro SS or a Mustang GT? Honest opinions please!

NOT trying to start WWIII. Just if given a choice would you purchase a Camaro agian?

I passed on a 2012 Shelby they had at the dealer
where I bought my 010 SS/RS [they are also Chevy dealer] for insurance
reasons 2,800 a year, sticker price 60k on the Shelby.
I saw a sold GT premium Grabber blue with the appearance package
that includes hood scoop, quarter window louvers,side scoops,
black rear panel and spoiler. It has the sport interior black with blue stripe and flat black racing stripes from front bumper to rear.
There are a few expensive items Ford charges for that are included in the Camaro
Brembo's on all four wheels Camaro front only on Mustang [1600.00] HID lights, [950.00] heated seats[695.00 with security pkg], 20" wheels
It's a six speed manual 5.0 they are also a Roush dealer and the car they sold
had Roush axle backs I requested them to be installed on mine when I saw the customer disclosure there was a dealer installed option of 2k added
that didn't last long he said the mufflers cost 9 hundred and 2 hours labor
I can get the mufflers for 389.00 right from Roush and about 1 hour to install,
no pipe cutting on the Ford ,they tried!
The deal was unbelievable 30,500 trade with a 6,900 difference, tax and tags
and document fees included.
I test drove a Roush stage 3 with a 3:73 gear what a difference that makes
over the 3:47 in my SS so I ordered that for an added 395
it adds about 500 rpm at any speed over the SS
I'm not knocking my SS just time for a change
It will be here in about 3 months

[BATMANs]

Originally Posted by 8cd03gro

9. BATMANs - GTO and NSX

ha ha.

nice.

I was wondering if anyone noticed.

[BATMANs]

Originally Posted by 08-G35s/6MT

Mustang=Camry, in terms of how common they are.

Some how I just don't get that feeling with the new 5.0.

I've seen 2 so far since they've been out.

As a matter of fact I see more "F" and "P" and even "L" cars than the 5.0.

[8cd03gro]

Originally Posted by BATMANs

Some how I just don't get that feeling with the new 5.0.

I've seen 2 so far since they've been out.

As a matter of fact I see more "F" and "P" and even "L" cars than the 5.0.

Well, it's not about making sense here apparently. Everyone talks about how the camaro has been outselling the mustang constantly, but then insist that there are way more 5.0s running around than fifth gens. . . uuuuuuuhhhh?

[Devryn17]

Originally Posted by 8cd03gro

1. Devryn17 - camaro
2. mikeSS - camaro
3. sixty4 - corvettes
4. BigDan - gt500 (the lone mustang)
5. PM Designs - camaro and trucks
6. brandotron - camaro
7. Dr.Pat - mercedes
8. newagemuscle - camaro
9. BATMANs - GTO and NSX
10. Sarah - camaro
11. Cristoff - camaro
12. a_Username - camaro
13. NBC/CGM - camaro

1/13. I MIGHT give you 12 or 11 for not including yourself and the OP. Still nowhere near 20% and only one mustang owner. Hardly the overwhelming amount of mustang owners in the thread like you were suggesting.

Maybe you should take your own advice

It APPEARED that MikeSS owned a Mustang. Despite my mistake, you were still trying to be an ass, since 2/11 is a lot f'n closer to 20%.

[8cd03gro]

Originally Posted by Devryn17

It APPEARED that MikeSS owned a Mustang. Despite my mistake, you were still trying to be an ass, since 2/11 is a lot f'n closer to 20%.

1/11.

I apologize if I came off as an ass, but it's truly obnoxious the level of talk we have about the mustang owners. In reality, there are really not that many here and the only reason there is a significant detraction from discussion about the camaro is because of people continually complaining about how many mustang owners and mustang threads by mustang owners there are. . . but the majority of the mustang threads are by camaro owners and there are only 4-5 mustang owners running around, especially after the recent banning spree.

[Devryn17]

It's my first comment on the matter, and there are alot of "other" car owners on this board that are allowed to troll and are extremely active posters. Of course, there are far more posters on this board that either own or like the new Camaro and don't have a CLUE about cars in general...And honestly just say some really ignorant feces. This place is as bad as almost any "newbie" car forum I've been apart of...S10 forums, Toyota Forums....Etc.

[Cbrenthus]

Simple answer: Whichever one you like better is the better car.


I really wanted to like the Mustang, but I'm just a chevy and Camaro guy at heart. Plus, I thought that the Camaro was priced better with the Brembos included on all 4 wheels rather than just the front for extra cash on the Mustang.

The Mustang does perform slightly better, but by slightly, I mean slightly. I love how people like to act as though its comparing a Mac truck to a Bugatti, but in reality, the differences are so small you won't really know. Its not like one of them really stands out, like getting 5mpg better, or a full second in the 1/4 or whatever.



I used to go through this with crotch rocket guys always debating between which was the best bike and my advice was always the same: sit on them and look at them, whichever one feels and looks the best to you is the better one, because the comfort and cosmetic differences are thousands of times more noticeable than the performance differences.

[chain777]

Originally Posted by BATMANs

Some how I just don't get that feeling with the new 5.0.

I've seen 2 so far since they've been out.

As a matter of fact I see more "F" and "P" and even "L" cars than the 5.0.

The other day I took a 40 mile round trip drive, and counted 8 new Camaros. Two were SS's. I spotted 0 2010+ Mustangs. I've only seen one 5.0 so far and only a handful of V6's. I still haven't spotted a GT500. I'm surprised by the lack of new Mustangs I see around here compared to Camaros, since the sales numbers aren't that far apart.

*btw, I'm in far west suburban Chicago.

[2010SLVRBULIT]

unless it's a GT500, most likely a Camaro...and alot more mustang sightings around here.:(

[UT-Engineer]

Ive seen more SS the 5.0s but both seem like very great cars. Have u considered the SRT8? Facts are Facts so if u want the better performer get the 5.0. When it comes to opinions the Camaro looks better. But you really shouldnt be asking others what u want... go with what you like, afterall you'll be the one driving it (and paying for it).

[BATMANs]

U would think that the new mustangs would move like Hot Cakes.

V6 one gets 30/31MPGs on the freeway with 300HP.

The 5.0 ain't that shabby at the mid 20's in MPGs.

The new 5.0 is about dead even (with solid axle) with the M3 in all the performance tests. and it does that at about the price of V6 stang.

I'm wondering if Ford screwed themselves by introducing 300HP on a Mustang V6. Something tells me that most people that drive mustangs have a tight budget, but also want a some performance. it looks like 300HP on the V6 was enough and that the 5.0 was overkill for the price/performance ratio.

[chain777]

Mustangs are selling just fine. One good indicator is the amount of time one sits on the lot before it sells. Both the Camaro and Mustang are moving off the lots pretty quickly.





http://blogs.cars.com/kickingtires/2...cking+Tires%29

[cruznls]

Since we have 3 Camaros & 2 Firebirds, anyone can tell what my answer is...
Honestly I think they ruined the look of the new Mustang
by changing the rear tail lights & the Front end....
As for Performance goes...
Camaro beats the Mustang sittin' still......

[HeaterMan]

I owned a 2SS manual trans car for a year and then traded it in on an Auto equipped 5.0, my honest opinion is that the Camaro has a better selection of options and a fresher look. the mustang retains the classic styling and in my experience has a hands down performance advantage. I prefer the solid rear axle of the mustyang but others prefer the independant suspension of the Camaro. the Camaro paint was one of my biggest concerns and so far it seems the mustang paint is doing better.

[derklug]

Drive them both and see what speaks to you. Both cars are great, but one will let you know that it is the ONE.

[AZ MSCL]

Originally Posted by sixty4

Thinking about pulling the trigger. My problem is a friend owns a 2ss and says its kind of boring? I drove it not all that bad. Says the performance is just not there? If he had to do it again said he would go with a Mustang.
So my problem is a Camaro SS or a Mustang GT? Honest opinions please!

NOT trying to start WWIII. Just if given a choice would you purchase a Camaro agian?

Are you seriously asking this question on a Camaro forum? Ask it on a Mustang forum and see what happens. That said, if you want power and speed (stock) the 5.0 hands down. The Camaro also has significant visibility issues. Both have about the same interior room, neither has a backseat to write home about. Camaro's top end stereo is better than the Mustang's (sound) but the Mustang's display (and navigation) is superior.

Regardless, both are great cars. You really need to go drive them and make your decision based upon which feels the best. Asking this question on Mustang or Camaro forums isn't going to result in what you are seeking but you might try digging around (quietly) and see what issues people are having with each. Seriously, you need to go drive them both, open the hood and trunk, play with the radio and look at other features.

Personally, I would go with the fully loaded 5.0, or if it's in your price range, the Boss (it is a real monster).

[BATMANs]

Originally Posted by HeaterMan

I owned a 2SS manual trans car for a year and then traded it in on an Auto equipped 5.0, my honest opinion is that the Camaro has a better selection of options and a fresher look. the mustang retains the classic styling and in my experience has a hands down performance advantage. I prefer the solid rear axle of the mustyang but others prefer the independant suspension of the Camaro. the Camaro paint was one of my biggest concerns and so far it seems the mustang paint is doing better.

I heard from my friend that the Mustang in 2014 will be IRS as standard.

[L99CAMA2011]

While the Mustang GT has the 5.0L Coyote going for it, the Camaro SS has a rigid more well built chassis going for it, I once saw a video where a 2006 GT with roll cage crashed and landed on it's roof and the roof caved in similar to having no roll cage, that scared the crap out of me, The 2005 to 2009, and 2010 to current Mustang chassis are still S197s.

[Bay Area SS]

My opinion is by far get the SS Camaro. I love mine more as time passes. I will admit that the HP is not mind boggling, but its not bad either and with some cash and time these cars have plenty of potential. I have owned a 67 RS/SS Camaro, 68 Z 28 Camaro, 2001 SS Camaro, 2010 RS/SS Camaro..1997 Mustang GT drop top, 2004 Mach1 Mustang and a 2006 Mustang GT. So im not biased cuz I have owned them both. The BOWTIE RULES