View Single Post
Old 11-15-2009, 03:42 AM   #151
Supermans
Camaro & Stang Enthusiast
 
Supermans's Avatar
 
Drives: 2011 Mustang 5.0 in Kona Blue
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Miami
Posts: 4,729
Quote:
Originally Posted by CamaroSpike23 View Post
absurd as it may sound, its the only way that YOU can be sure. GM said this car would run 13.3 stock in the 1/4 mile.... but yet we've got stock cars going faster than that.

I cant tell you if your car is affected or not. I'm telling you the only guaranteed way to find out is to go try and break it. because if the vin range of affected vehicles comes out to be skewed, or another bad batch made its way in, the only way of finding out is by having the shaft break.
you arent asking for too much wanting the safety of knowing your car will hold up. but if your dealer tries to deny a warranty claim because you were pushing your car, thats complete bs and a completely different situation that needs to be dealt with.

the true problem is HOW do you tell if its defective without testing the shaft itself. how does GM test that? ok, there was a specific range where they know that there were bad parts being sent out... but how often to bad parts still slip thru the cracks? just like the A-pillars that were falling off of cars upon delivery... a lot stayed on, but some didnt.
Not saying that they shouldnt be a little more open about whats going on.






imagine this. say you are GM. and say one shaft in every 1000 broke, and you've sold, say 10,000 of them. so now you have a total of 10 shafts that will break in 10,000. how much financial sense does it make to recall every single one of those 10,000 vehicles to replace 10 bad shafts?
or you wait it out until those 10 shafts break on the road, then you replace them as they come. much cheaper and feasable.


now, do not take that scenario to heart. that is just pure speculation on what may or may not be happening.



I honestly wish I could just say that everything will be all right and no one else will have to deal with this, but I cant. all I can say is to go and have fun with the car. for the time being, if it breaks, it breaks. and thats exactly what your warranty was designed for.
So what your saying is the cause of the breakage has only occurred during launching using launch control? If so, is there enough data from all the people who had this issue to compile exactly what stress the Camaro's not affected should handle vs the ones that have the faulty part? In other words, what would be the average of launches I must try and exactly what numbers are we talking about so there is a way to test this out for ourselves. I'll try to re-phrase it in another way.. Perhaps we should get a formula of what we can do with the Camaro under warranty that either A: breaks the shaft or B: does not break the shaft so Camaro is working normally.. Unless you are saying all Camaro's are susceptible to launch control causing this issue which camaro5 has theorized. Just let us know the facts and how we can go about testing this ourselves (I don't like to use the word breaking it) so we can have peace of mind since GM is not willing to do it for us. Thanks for your input and help with this at this point in time. Better late than never..
__________________
Bought my Camaro from Eric Hall(817) 421-7266
Supermans is offline