Appreciate the feedback. If you go to their site, SLP charges $2500 for the black rims with Toyo tires:
http://www.slponline.com/browse_list_site.asp
Since they don't sell the red lines and the ones I'm selling have Pirellis it is apples and oranges, but I understand it comes down to what people are willing to pay. I am willing to entertain any reasonable offers people would like to make. Thanks everyone.