I'd say that humans in general have a mob mentality.
But no, I'm not trying to make any veiled insinuations against Camaro5 forum posters.
I think the discussion is great, people just need to understand that there's a counterpoint. If I'm Joe Anybody, and this is the forum I come to to get technical info about my car, when I see this thread I'm going to think that cats are failing all the time on supercharged motors, and that isn't the case. Now that we're 8 pages in, we have a rough estimate of failures that Ted has seen. It seems to jibe with the failures MarylandSpeed has seen as well. Namely, out of all the catted supercharger installs they have done, there have been a mere handful of failures.
Nobody is saying that failures aren't happening, or that they are not more common in FI setups. That's pretty widely accepted. However, it's not a pervasive enough issue that anyone should be running out to gut their cats. The chances of a cat failing are very small, aside from an external causality such as a lean tune producing abnormally high EGTs, for example.