Roto Fab or C.A.I. Intake?

[67motorcat]

The ADM scoop is way worth it IMHO.I have the Roto-Fab washer bottle as well.

I have felt the Temp of the chrome ring on the end of the filter after a drive.
It is definatly ALOT cooler to the touch than the surrounding engine compartment metal parts.
Even the sheild of the Roto-Fab enclosure is cooler to the touch.
A sure sign cooler air is entering the engine.
In the hot summer months is has got to make a huge difference on AIT.

[Sales @ CAI Inc]

To the original poster, call me and I can discuss in great technical detail the design and engineering behind our system. The choice is obviously up to you but I think I can bring some items to your attention that will make the choice a little simpler if you are tied on looks and are simply looking for performance at this point.

[Jcobra]

Originally Posted by Bill @ CAI Inc

To the original poster, call me and I can discuss in great technical detail the design and engineering behind our system. The choice is obviously up to you but I think I can bring some items to your attention that will make the choice a little simpler if you are tied on looks and are simply looking for performance at this point.

Can you justify the extra $90 for your system keeping in mind roto fab has improved theirs. Feel free to pm me if you'd like.

[kpwalls06]

C.A.I. for me, mostly because I like the look. The guy building my new stroker motor sells and backs the Roto-fab, so either way seems to be a solid choice. But I can say that I feel a quicker throttle response, slightly more power paired with my magnaflow cat-back, and I like the tone at WOT better too. Good luck, you'll enjoy it!!

*Note: All the pro's I listed are over stock. I have no basis for comparison to other mfg cai systems.

[Roto-fab 1]

Our system works great for stock vehicles and will perform extremely well should you decide to go with further mods. As you can see, our air box effectively seals to the hood which means you get all of the advantages of a lid without the restriction. As you increase power levels our intake design and large filter really make a difference.
We offer a large variety of options including:
dry or oil filter
custom air box colors
Plastic, stainless steel or carbon fiber finish inlet elbow
black, red or yellow hose couplers

[L99CAMA2011]

Not a fan of intakes with metal intake tubes at all but I did buy CAI inc. intake in black weeks ago from Janetty. This is what I ended up with weeks after, an AFE intake filter from my 2007 Mustang GT and the black elbow is now coated with 3 coats of ceramic paint. Criticize or not, this setup is way better and way more responsive now than the stock CAI inc setup. And also notice my lid is off, yes off since I notice that having it on doesn't allow the air flow from down bottom where the bottle is to channel freely upwards. I will never and I repeat will never go back to the stock CAI setup just my 02. cents. Even with a Janetty tune and the CAI intake I still found myself not contented. Now with this setup I find myself having a very hard time parking my car. Now it feels like a catapult on an aircraft carrier and my Camaro SS is an F18 Hornet, or in other words the engine responds soooooo damn quickly to throttle input you would this is a 4 valve per cylinder head instead of 2 valves per cylinder. Now I'm worried my half shafts drive shafts are going to go a lot sooner than I thought. I have also been through 2 and 3/4 tanks of gas since Friday 04/22/11. Can't stop driving my baby.

[L99CAMA2011]

Oh and you guys with more than 6000 miles on their cars who do burn outs and so on. How much abuse do these drive shaft half shafts take before they break. Also Livernois Motorsports pushes Roto Fab big time and I have huge faith in Livernois. I was even thinking of switching my metal, heat soaking elbowed CAI intake for a Roto Fab or Vararam, but since I did my own customization I am now somewhat contented, until the hot summer heat comes a knocking on my door. However as far as looks are concerned, I actually liked my CAI inc. intake in black with the lid on a lot, it matched and looked like a factory CAI upgrade sitting in my engine bay, but it was the heat soak that caused noticible power loss that caused me to begin my customization no offense to CAI inc. This AFE filter you see here allows more airflow and it is very noticeable . Maybe CAI inc should make another version with a filter like this one and a plastic elbow that doesn't attract much heat.

[JorgeSS]

Roto-Fab hands down!

[Sales @ CAI Inc]

Originally Posted by Jcobra

Can you justify the extra $90 for your system keeping in mind roto fab has improved theirs. Feel free to pm me if you'd like.

Ne need to PM on this one. This is good information that everyone could benefit from. To address cost of our CAI vs others (not just the brand you mentioned) I can answer that without even talking about superior design and performance and answer it simply from a manufacturing stand-point.

-Our boxes and intake tubes are aluminum and are each TIG welded by hand individually $$$
-They include a lid that includes a clear view window and spring loaded quarter turn fasteners $$$
-The filters are our own design which require their own tooling and manufacturing as opposed to a standard cone filter that anyone can just purchase $$$
-The intake tubes are ceramic coated inside and out which is a entirely different manufacturing proccess $$$

Basically we have more materials and labor hours (as well as more expensive materials) that goes into the manufacturing of these systems when compared to many on the market. The way we manufacture is based of our design, which is engineered specifically for optimal performance. I hope this answers your question.

Originally Posted by L99CAMA2011

Not a fan of intakes with metal intake tubes at all but I did buy CAI inc. intake in black weeks ago from Janetty. This is what I ended up with weeks after, an AFE intake filter from my 2007 Mustang GT and the black elbow is now coated with 3 coats of ceramic paint. Criticize or not, this setup is way better and way more responsive now than the stock CAI inc setup. And also notice my lid is off, yes off since I notice that having it on doesn't allow the air flow from down bottom where the bottle is to channel freely upwards. I will never and I repeat will never go back to the stock CAI setup just my 02. cents. Even with a Janetty tune and the CAI intake I still found myself not contented. Now with this setup I find myself having a very hard time parking my car. Now it feels like a catapult on an aircraft carrier and my Camaro SS is an F18 Hornet, or in other words the engine responds soooooo damn quickly to throttle input you would this is a 4 valve per cylinder head instead of 2 valves per cylinder. Now I'm worried my half shafts drive shafts are going to go a lot sooner than I thought. I have also been through 2 and 3/4 tanks of gas since Friday 04/22/11. Can't stop driving my baby.

I was even thinking of switching my metal, heat soaking elbowed CAI intake for a Roto Fab or Vararam, but since I did my own customization I am now somewhat contented, until the hot summer heat comes a knocking on my door. However as far as looks are concerned, I actually liked my CAI inc. intake in black with the lid on a lot, it matched and looked like a factory CAI upgrade sitting in my engine bay, but it was the heat soak that caused noticible power loss that caused me to begin my customization no offense to CAI inc. This AFE filter you see here allows more airflow and it is very noticeable . Maybe CAI inc should make another version with a filter like this one and a plastic elbow that doesn't attract much heat.

Well first off thanks for purchasing our system. In reference to your post (which you are completely entitled to) I would have to respectfully disagree with a lot of what you are saying, and I would back up those disputes with many hours of thermal imaging, hundreds of dyno pulls, testing of intake air temps, flow bench testing, flow simulations on the intake tube, and some basic engineering principles. Let me address just a few things that you made mention to:

1. The whole "heat soak" issue and the metal being hot to the touch, and using metal as opposed to plastic that you mentioned...the intake tube is supposed to be hot to the touch because the ceramic coating that is applied to the inside and outside of the tube is stopping the heat from soaking through to the intake air! We don't care if the outside of the tube is hot, we care about the air traveling through the tube. Why do you suppose all of our intake air temps are low when the system is ever tested, it's because the heat is not soaking through the ceramic coating. All of the thermal imaging and intake air testing proves this theory.

2. Taking the lig of the system . The whole point of the design on our system is to block the hot air from the engine bay and pull from the cooler air outside. If you want to increase air flow, relocate the washer bottle, don't take off the lid. You can forget all the ceramic coating now because you are allowing the system to suck in hot air from the engine bay right from the start. The only time your car could ever benefit from taking the lid off is if the hood was open, which is irrevelant because you don't drive with the hood open.

3. The filters...I could write abook on this one but I am going to keep it short, well I would love to see the testing behind that filter vs ours for your Camaro. We designed that filter for the Camaro specifically, I can guruantee that our filter flows better than the one you put on there. We have hours of flow testing that will prove a oiled filter will flow better than a non-oiled filter. Not to mention we designed a smooth bore tube stop and velocity stack that greatly increases flow, and I can promise you that your filter does not have those features because it is our own design!

4. Coating it yourself with 3 additional coats of "ceramic paint" We use an industrial ceramic coating rated up to 2000 degrees that is baked on in an oven at 400+ degrees. Your black system was already ceramic coated inside and out and then received an additional powder coat over that! Once its ceramic coated properly inside and out the job is done. I doubt that a spray can of "ceramic paint" from the local autozone had the same results as our ceramic coating proccess.

Like I said, you are entitled to your opinion and I refuse to get in a back in forth on this one, but when someone reads your posts and has questions regarding why we do what we do I want them to realize we have a lot of engineering and testing that goes into and backs up our intakes other than just what people feel. Again, no hard feelings, but its my job to educate on our products and this one was needed.

[n116ebo]

I have the CAI Inc, I like the plexiglass closed top seal verses sealing against the hood. the looks of the shiny intake looks good, and the extra horsepower gain is a plus. Oh! did I mention how easy it was to install.

[FurySS]

Lots of great options out there, but I chose CAI as I felt it had the better appearance for the price I was paying. By the time I added the color matched paint, & polished tube the Roto-Fab price increased substantially. Definitely was a tough decision, both seem great.

I considered adding the ADM scoop as well but with the washer relocation kit that tacks on another $175 or so. Maybe later...

[chevyfan#1]

I have a CAI Inc. setup and its fricken awesome!!! I like the whole idea behind what they do and have been really happy, especially with throttle response and the increased fuel economy I have seen. A buddy of mine has a bone stock SS with a Roto-Fab and anytime we do a litlle road race mine always wins!! We switched drivers and then he won with my car with the CAI Inc! I am sure its not the most scientific of tests but mine is definitey faster and other than the intakes they are identical and stock. Next I am doing headers and exhaust!

[McBeevee]

Originally Posted by chevyfan#1

........I am sure its not the most scientific of tests ......

You're definitely right about that

[MaddogZ28]

I just installed the CAI. Very easy install and some of the best directions i have ever read.

It sounds a bit deeper than stock.

Here's a video stock vs CAI i took yesterday. http://www.camaro5.com/forums/showthread.php?t=143846