I'm 80% leaning for Auto right now: based on my needs, circumstances. But I definitely want the paddles - or it's manual.
I've sat in a 'Vette, and they just feel...right. Some argue that Auto's, no matter what kind, forces you to feel detached from the car; separated. When I was sitting in that 'vette, boy let me tell you - the connection couldn't have been stronger. And with what the majority of people who's driven with them keeps saying - I'm very much looking forward to a paddle-shift, Auto Camaro.