Personally, I prefer the Camaro's style.
I drove a CTS and a G8 GT with the Charger's style shifter...and it just felt..."heavy" to me. Not crisp in any sense of the word, imo. I have yet to drive a paddle-shifter vehicle, but I sat in a 'Vette and played with
that version (which is slightly different than Camaro's) and the driver engagement seemed more sporty to me.