Sales, and public-impression wise; it's Mustang vs Camaro all the way. The Challenger is geared more towards baby-boomers, and the retro guys more than the general public, imho, to be of any concern.
Performance? Camaro will stomp all over both of them. Think about it: 400+hp, with hundreds of pounds less wieght than the Challenger AND thousands of dollars less moneys! You tell me who's going to win that?
Yep; I'm talking "base V8" vs SRT8; even though they're not even in the same trim level!!!!!!
(disclamer: the rumored 6.4 HEMI is a different story.
)